DeGette Calls on Obama Administration to End Family Detention

May 27, 2015

WASHINGTON – U.S. Rep. Diana DeGette called on Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson to end the Obama Administration's policy of detaining mothers and children involved in deportation proceedings in jail-like facilities. Rep. DeGette and 135 of her colleagues raised issues ranging from excessive confinement, delays in due process, developmental problems for children, and serious medical concerns in a letter to Secretary Johnson.

"We must prioritize the health and well-being of mothers and children while also prioritizing our enforcement objectives," wrote Rep. DeGette and her colleagues. "Detaining mothers and children in jail-like settings is not the answer. We have an opportunity to do the right thing and are confident that DHS has the capacity to honor our Nation's longstanding commitment both to the protection and well-being of refugee families and to law enforcement and public safety."

Detention policies by the Department of Homeland Security have come under increasing scrutiny, and the letter by Rep. DeGette and her colleagues detailed some of the most disturbing problems affecting some of the most vulnerable individuals being held by the department. DeGette has also called for an end to the department's policy to set a number of beds to always be occupied in detention facilities, which creates an incentive to detain individuals who do not pose a threat to public safety, and urged the department to end the use of immigration detainers.

The full text of the letter is available below and at this link.

May 27, 2015

Secretary Jeh Johnson
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Washington, DC 20528

Dear Secretary Johnson:

We are troubled by the Department of Homeland Security's continued detention of mothers and children in secure, jail-like facilities. For nearly one year we have been closely following the troublesome conditions of confinement, due process issues, and serious developmental and medical concerns of those being detained. Many of us have raised these matters in writing and continue to bring concerns to DHS through individual case examples and systemic complaints. We believe your Department has heard many of our concerns but has not fully grasped the serious harm being inflicted upon mothers and children in custody. We believe the only solution to this problem is to end the use of family detention.

The recent announcement by Immigration and Customs Enforcement on family detention does not acknowledge that even detention for a brief period of time, especially in a secure setting, is detrimental to child development. Based upon his 39 years of clinical experience and interviews with families at the Karnes Residential Center, the Dean of Social Work at the University of Texas, Dr. Luis Zayas, found that the children at Karnes are "facing some of the most adverse childhood conditions of any children I have ever interviewed or evaluated."[1] In his affidavit, Dean Zayas concluded that "[d]etention has had serious and long-lasting impacts on the psychological health and well-being" of the families at Karnes and that these impacts were evident in families who were detained for as little as two weeks.

We believe it is undeniable that detention in a secure facility is detrimental to mothers and
children and is not reflective of our values as a Nation. Children require special protections and should not be placed in jail-like settings.

We are particularly troubled by the current practice of family detention because the detained population is largely comprised of refugees fleeing violence and persecution in their home countries. We have heard horrific stories of sexual assault, intense physical violence, kidnapping, and sex trafficking. These stories come not only from adult mothers, but also from young children who have been victims of such abuse. Detaining children who have already been victims of abuse exacerbates past trauma and raises unique and serious problems.

DHS has repeatedly used deterrence as a justification for the existence of family detention, but this theory has not been substantiated with compelling evidence. Moreover, a federal court in the District of Columbia rejected this argument and found that DHS cannot detain asylum-seeking mothers and children from Central America for the purpose of deterring other migrants from entering the country.[2] We agree and believe that the hypothetical recurrence of a future refugee flow does not justify the very real harm being inflicted upon mothers and children in a secure setting.

Lastly, we are disturbed by the fact that many mothers and children remain in family detention despite serious medical needs. In the past year, we have learned of the detention of children with intellectual disabilities, a child with brain cancer, a mother with a congenital heart disorder, a 14-day-old baby, and a 12-year-old child who has not eaten solid food for two months, among many others. Recently, we learned of a three-year-old child at the Berks County Residential Center who was throwing up for three days and was apparently offered water as a form of medical treatment. It was only after the child began throwing up blood on the fourth day that the facility finally transferred her to a hospital.[3] This is simply unacceptable. We cannot continue to hear reports of serious harm to children in custody and do nothing about it.

We must prioritize the health and well-being of mothers and children while also prioritizing our enforcement objectives. Detaining mothers and children in jail-like settings is not the answer. We have an opportunity to do the right thing and are confident that DHS has the capacity to honor our Nation's longstanding commitment both to the protection and well-being of refugee families and to law enforcement and public safety.

Sincerely,
________________________ ________________________ ________________________
Hon. Zoe Lofgren Hon. Lucille Roybal-Allard Hon. Luis V. Gutiérrez

______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Nancy Pelosi, Democratic Leader Hon. Steny H. Hoyer, Democratic Whip
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. John Conyers, Jr. Hon. Charles B. Rangel
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Marcy Kaptur Hon. Eliot L. Engel
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Nita M. Lowey Hon. José E. Serrano
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. David E. Price Hon. Rosa L. DeLauro
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Maxine Waters Hon. Jerrold Nadler
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Corrine Brown Hon. Gene Green
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Alcee L. Hastings Hon. Eddie Bernice Johnson
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Carolyn B. Maloney Hon. Nydia M. Velázquez
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Lloyd Doggett Hon. Chaka Fattah
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Sheila Jackson Lee Hon. Elijah E. Cummings
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Danny K. Davis Hon. Diana DeGette
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Rubén Hinojosa Hon. Adam Smith
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Gregory W. Meeks Hon. Lois Capps
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Barbara Lee Hon. Janice D. Schakowsky
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Steve Israel Hon. Rick Larsen
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Betty McCollum Hon. Adam B. Schiff
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Linda T. Sánchez Hon. G. K. Butterfield
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Emanuel Cleaver Hon. Al Green
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Gwen Moore Hon. Doris O. Matsui
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Albio Sires Hon. Yvette D. Clarke
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Steve Cohen Hon. Keith Ellison
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Henry C. "Hank" Johnson, Jr. Hon. Jerry McNerney
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Peter Welch Hon. Donna F. Edwards
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Gerald E. Connolly Hon. Ben Ray Luján
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Chellie Pingree Hon. Paul Tonko
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Mike Quigley Hon. Judy Chu
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. John Garamendi Hon. Theodore E. Deutch
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. David N. Cicilline Hon. Eleanor Holmes Norton
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Pedro R. Pierluisi Hon. Ruben Gallego
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Sander M. Levin Hon. Jim McDermott
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Xavier Becerra Hon. Robert C. "Bobby" Scott
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Sam Farr Hon. Earl Blumenauer
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Ron Kind Hon. Loretta Sanchez
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Michael E. Capuano Hon. Joseph Crowley
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. John B. Larson Hon. Grace F. Napolitano
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Susan A. Davis Hon. Michael M. Honda
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Raúl M. Grijalva Hon. Tim Ryan
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Chris Van Hollen Hon. Jared Polis
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Bill Foster Hon. Julia Brownley
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Tony Cardenas Hon. Lois Frankel
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Jared Huffman Hon. Hakeem S. Jeffries
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Derek Kilmer Hon. Grace Meng
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Beto O'Rourke Hon. Raul Ruiz
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Mark Takano Hon. Juan Vargas
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Robin L. Kelly Hon. Katherine M. Clark
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Donald Norcross Hon. Pete Aguilar
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. John Lewis Hon. Frank Pallone, Jr.
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. James E. Clyburn Hon. Anna G. Eshoo
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Michael F. Doyle Hon. James P. McGovern
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Robert A. Brady Hon. Frederica S. Wilson
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Kathy Castor Hon. John A. Yarmuth
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Karen Bass Hon. Cedric L. Richmond
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Janice Hahn Hon. Suzan K. DelBene
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Donald M. Payne, Jr. Hon. Alan Grayson
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Dina Titus Hon. Joaquin Castro
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Tammy Duckworth Hon. Joseph P. Kennedy, III
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Daniel T. Kildee Hon. Alan Lowenthal
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Michelle Lujan Grisham Hon. Mark Pocan
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Eric Swalwell Hon. Marc A. Veasey
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Donald S. Beyer, Jr. Hon. Bonnie Watson Coleman
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Mark DeSaulnier Hon. Debbie Dingell
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Ted Lieu Hon. Mark Takai
______________________________ ______________________________
Hon. Norma J. Torres Hon. Gregorio Kilili Camacho Sablan
______________________________ ______________________________

###